Login
Subscribe
Basketball

Cavaliers face huge dilemma after Knicks sweep: Blow it up or go for broke?

By No Comments32 Mins Read

The end for the Cleveland Cavaliers was cruel, with Timothée Chalamet and Kylie Jenner celebrating on their court dressed in New York Knicks gear and embracing Knicks’ players like they were part of the win. The Knicks’ blowout put them in the NBA Finals for the first time since 1999 and sent the Cavaliers into an uncomfortable offseason.

Though Cleveland advanced to the Eastern Conference finals without LeBron James for the first time in almost 35 years, its unceremonious exit – and how arduous this whole postseason run seemed – has clouded what path the team should take in the weeks and months ahead.

Advertisement

The Cavaliers took perhaps the biggest swing of any team this year at the NBA trade deadline, flipping oft-injured 26-year-old Darius Garland for durable 36-year-old James Harden to pair with Donovan Mitchell in the backcourt. Cleveland had the most expensive roster in the league. Whether it worked – or can work – is up for debate. The final impression this season was a dud.

After blowing a 22-point lead in the fourth quarter of Game 1 against the Knicks, the Cavaliers lost the last three games of the Eastern Conference finals by an average of 22 points.

1 / 103

Victor Wembanyama leads Spurs to a huge win in double OT. See game highlights

Oklahoma City Thunder fans react during Game 1 of the Western Conference finals against the San Antonio Spurs at Paycom Center on May 18, 2026.

(Alonzo Adams, Imagn Images)

Harden said in the aftermath he is committed to remaining with the Cavaliers. Mitchell told reporters he has “no doubt this group can get there.” They each expressed faith in coach Kenny Atkinson and the organization. They preached patience after only a few months with Harden in the fold.

But the modern NBA doesn’t usually wait around for long. Team owner Dan Gilbert said as much in a postgame tweet declaring, “we took a step ahead this spring, but we are nowhere near where we need to be.”

Advertisement

How that statement manifests itself could change the landscape of the entire NBA offseason, with the Cavaliers possessing perhaps the largest range of outcomes of any team in the league. They could stay the course, blow it up, or go for broke. These are the pressing questions facing the franchise:

NYC MAYOR: Zohran Mamdani talks trash after Knicks sweep to reach NBA Finals

Will Donovan Mitchell, Cavaliers sign new extension?

Mitchell just made his first trip to the conference finals in his ninth NBA season, and fourth with the Cavaliers. But there’s a fork-in-the-road for the two sides, despite Mitchell’s statements in the wake of Monday’s loss that he remains committed to Cleveland.

Advertisement

The 29-year-old is eligible to sign a four-year extension worth as much as $272 million this offseason. He could also wait until next year and be eligible to sign a five-year deal worth as much as $350 million. If he chooses the latter path, he’d essentially play next season as a looming free agent because of the $54-million player option for 2027-28 in his current contract.

Are the Cavaliers comfortable devoting that much to a player who might not be a No. 1 option for a championship contender right now? The uncertainty shouldn’t immediately invite trade rumors, especially given Mitchell’s positive tone after being swept out of the playoffs. But there’s a forthcoming negotiation that will determine how much Cleveland wants to spend to hitch its wagon to Mitchell for the foreseeable future.

What’s next for James Harden, Cavaliers?

Harden has a $42.3-million team option on his contract for the 2026-27 season, but multiple reports at the trade deadline suggested Harden would not have agreed to be dealt to the Cavaliers without an understanding that he would be retained beyond this season.

Advertisement

He had another bumpy postseason, with a few notable performances in the first two rounds that got overshadowed when Knicks star Jalen Brunson feasted on him in the Eastern Conference Finals. Taking on Harden at his team option price tag would likely hamper what else the Cavaliers can do this offseason. A more team-friendly salary point, likely in exchange for an extra year or two on a new Harden contract, is expected to be the outcome.

That will tie Cleveland to Mitchell and Harden as a tandem. Harden sounded confident it can work.

“Definitely want to be here,” Harden told reporters after Game 4. “I think we found something. It’s tough. It’s not ending how we wanted to, but I think we found something.”

1 / 11

New York Knicks fans take to the streets to celebrate reaching NBA Finals

New York Knicks fans celebrate winning the Eastern Conference championship against the Cleveland Cavaliers. The Knicks last reached the NBA Finals in 1999, falling to the San Antonio Spurs, and are seeking their first championship since defeating the Los Angeles Lakers in 1973.

(David Dee Delgado, Getty Images)

Will Cavaliers coach Kenny Atkinson be back?

Atkinson is just one year removed from winning NBA coach of the year, but his viral analytics moment before Game 4 reinforced his underwhelming performance on the sideline during the playoffs.

Advertisement

Telling reporters that Cleveland “analytically” won two of the first three games of the Eastern Conference Finals will go down in infamy among the more inopportune quotes uttered by a coach during a postseason series. It happened less than a week after Atkinson’s timeout usage, or lack thereof, was questioned after the Cavaliers blew their 22-point lead in Game 1.

Cleveland was also taken to Game 7 in both the first round and conference semifinals after having a chance to end both series in Game 6. The accumulation of wear and tear, according to Atkinson, took its toll on the roster in the Eastern Conference Finals. Given Gilbert’s postgame edict and expectations, Atkinson’s leash appears to be short whether he keeps his job going into next season or not.

Can Cavaliers land LeBron James or Giannis?

These are the ultimate wild cards for this Cleveland offseason, and the most unlikely scenarios. One relies on James being generous. The other would be a huge bet on the present, potentially at the expense of the franchise’s long-term fortunes. But James is a free agent and Giannis Antetokounmpo is reportedly on the trade market. One

Advertisement

In Evan Mobley, Cleveland has a young star the Milwaukee Bucks might be interested in taking back as a centerpiece in exchange for Antetokounmpo. The Cavaliers previously showed no interest in doing that. Did the Knicks sweep change their thinking?

James, meanwhile, has the option to add a closing chapter to his career by returning to Cleveland one more time. It would almost certainly have to come on a significant hometown discount given how much money the Cavaliers have committed. But if James is searching for another title and wants to leave the Lakers, he’d have an easier path in the Eastern Conference.

This article originally appeared on USA TODAY: Cavaliers NBA offseason, free agency outlook includes LeBron, Giannis

Read the full article here

Keep Reading

Leave A Reply

2026 © Prices.com LLC. All Rights Reserved.
Exit mobile version