Rutger McGroarty, last season’s top prospect in the Pensburgh rankings, slips back to No. 4 in the 2026 rankings after playing 24 games with the Penguins last season.
Catch up on the previous entries for this year:
Advertisement
Pensburgh Top 25 Under 25: Graduates and Departed players in 2025
Top 25 Under 25: The best of the rest
#25: Chase Pietila
#24: Ryan Miller
#23: Finn Harding
#22: Peyton Kettles
#21: Zam Plante
#21: Brady Peddle
#20: Melvin Fernstrom
#19: Tanner Howe
#18: Tomas Galvas
#17: Pierce Mbuyi
#16: Jake Livanavage
#15: Owen Pickering
#14: Tristan Broz
#13: Avery Hayes
#12: Ville Koivunen
#11: Hendrix Lapierre
#10: Markus Ruck
#9: Mikhail Ilyin
#8: Joel Blomqvist
#7: Liam Ruck
#6:Will Horcoff
#5: Bill Zonnon
#4: Rutger McGroarty
2025 Ranking: No. 1
Age: 22 (March 30, 2004)
Acquired Via: Aug. 28, 2024 trade with Winnipeg Jets involving Brayden Yager
Height/Weight: 6’1″, 212 pounds
Elite Prospects resume:
McGroarty is still looking to find solid footing in the NHL despite an extended call-up with the Penguins last winter.
Advertisement
He missed training camp due to an upper-body injury and began the season rehabbing before starting out the campaign with Wilkes/Barre-Scranton.
The winger was called up to the NHL from Dec. 1 to Jan. 3, a span over which he posted three points (two goals, one assist) in 16 games while averaging 12:13 per game with minimal time on special teams.
This first stint in the NHL ended with a concussion diagnosis, after which McGroarty was reassigned to Wilkes/Barre.
McGroarty played four AHL games after recovering from his concussion. He was called back up to the NHL on Jan. 29 and played another four games with the Penguins before the NHL split for the Olympic break.
Advertisement
He got his third recall of the season once the Penguins had already clinched a playoff spot in late March, scoring his third goal of the season in a regular season finale loss to the St. Louis Blues.
In part due to his usage, McGroarty wasn’t always an impact player in the NHL.
The same couldn’t be said for his work in the AHL last season. McGroarty celebrated his return to the WBS lineup at the beginning of the season by racking up four goals in his first four games back from injury in November.
McGroarty put together a point-per-game AHL campaign before playing a key role in helping Wilkes-Barre/Scranton on a run to the Eastern Conference Final.
Advertisement
McGroarty told Inside AHL Hockey’s Tony Androckitis after the season he saw the 2025-26 campaign as “a year of learning.”
“I think that, being between two teams, kind of having a few different roles helped me a lot mentally… going through those growing pains of going up and down, playing well here, maybe playing well there and not producing,” McGroarty said in June.
McGroarty is currently signed through next season before he is set to hit restricted free agency ahead of his age-23 campaign in 2027.
Especially in the wake of Ville Koivunen’s eight-year extension earlier this offseason, will McGroarty be able to earn himself the increased NHL playing time that could give him a better shot at making an impact with the Penguins?
Advertisement
One skill that’s gotten in the way of McGroarty making a full-time NHL jump before now is his skating, an area in which Kyle Dubas said in May he has seen improvement.
“He’s put in a lot of work. I think it’s evident when watching the games, for me, anyway,” Dubas said about McGroarty in May. “Especially without the puck on the forecheck, able to generate much more speed, pressure the opponents. I think that’s the type of game he’s going to have to play.”
Dubas continued, “I think, with Rutger, he’s proven to be an excellent penalty killer, excellent netfront power-play guy with Wilkes/Barre. The skating has always been the thing with him, and he’s put in the work, and improved on it.
“So we expect next year that he’ll have every opportunity to earn a spot here. How high in the lineup that is will be up to him, and earning a spot at large will be up to him.”
Advertisement
The Penguins’ forward depth and McGroarty’s contract could make this close to a make-or-break year for the 22-year-old winger.
He’ll be looking to earn a roster spot, and potentially some special teams playing time, out of training camp this fall. That will start with him staying in good health that allows him to stay with the team for the entirety of training camp next month.
Read the full article here