Sometimes baseball is weird. Sometimes it’s sloppy. Sometimes, neither team looks exceptionally sharp. But all of the time, someone has to win. The way this game started, it looked like it would last as long as those classic four-hour Yankees-Red Sox July marathons at Fenway, and although this one clocked in at three hours and 15 minutes officially, it felt the same as a 2026 version of a slog.
Both starters struggled early in a mess of baserunners, command, defense and baserunning woes, and a few dingers. Locked up at three in the seventh, Pete Alonso seemingly crushed his second homer of the game for the lead, but the umpires took a page out of the book of last April’s controversy at George M. Steinbrenner Field with an Aaron Judge home run and decided to refute what seemed like obvious video evidence to keep the call on the field.
Advertisement
In keeping the call on the field, Alonso and all Baltimore fans were furious, but were left eating sour grapes as the Yankees scraped two runs across in the eighth in an untraditional fashion, taking the lead on a George Lombard Jr. infield RBI single to win this one, 5-3, to secure this series and the season series against Baltimore.
The Yankees haven’t scored a run in the first inning since the four-run first-inning explosion against Davis Martin and the White Sox on July 30th, but it briefly looked like it might end tonight after consecutive ground-ball singles by Trent Grisham and Ben Rice led off the game. You’d hope, with the heart of the order up, that you’d get at least one of them in, but Luis García Jr. hit into a 4-6-3 double play, and Heliot Ramos hit a weak groundout to strand Grisham. That’s been how it’s going.
Will Warren came out struggling to throw strikes, and it would be something that would bite him later in the inning. A beautiful strikeout of Pete Alonso was sandwiched between a pair of walks and another 3-2 count that ultimately culminated in runners on the corners with two outs. On 1-1, Gunnar Henderson bolted for second base, and Austin Wells made the unwise decision to throw through. That move, coupled with Jazz Chisholm Jr. committing to the tag, allowed Jackson Holliday to scamper home on a delayed double steal, a rarity in the big leagues. ‘Twas a rough defensive inning for Wells, as the runner got to third because he didn’t challenge a crossed-up 2-2 pitch to Samuel Basallo one pitch before a flyout.
View Link
Advertisement
Bassitt got away with some poor pitching in the first, but he didn’t in the second. Chisholm worked a nice, six-pitch walk, Spencer Jones chopped a single through the right side, and Ryan McMahon laced a ball to right for a game-tying RBI single before being thrown out trying to get to second, his third baserunning miscue in the last week. Oof. Thankfully for him and the Yankees, George Lombard Jr. got Jones in anyway with a 350-foot sac fly to right-center to give them a 2-1 lead.
View Link
More shenanigans ensued in the bottom half, as Leody Taveras’ beautifully executed bunt caused a minor collision between McMahon and Warren that thankfully didn’t lead to anything bad in-game or injury-wise. Grisham almost picked Taveras off on a glove-flash deke in center with one out, but Warren ended the inning himself anyway with a strikeout of Carlos Narvaez.
This slow-moving affair rolled into the third, where Rice worked a long at-bat against Bassitt before absolutely pulverizing a fastball on the outer half for his 34th home run of the season, and his second in the last three games, to make it 3-1 Yankees. García and Ramos added singles later in the inning, but Chisholm was robbed of a hit by Basallo before Jones struck out to end the inning.
Advertisement
View Link
Warren continued to labor through this one, getting the first out of the third before being dragged into a long at-bat by the Polar Bear, who answered Rice with his own towering shot to right-center to cut it to 3-2. A double by Henderson and a hit-by-pitch threatened to have things unravel further, but the right-hander got the next two to end the inning.
View Link
After taking about 90 minutes to get through three innings and change, things finally sped up in the fourth. Bassitt settled in and looked much better over the back half of the game, getting through 5.2 innings before being lifted for Grant Wolfram, who’d strand Chisholm on second after a single and a stolen base. Warren finished up a four-inning, two-run outing that simultaneously felt like it should’ve been better, but could’ve been worse.
Advertisement
Tim Hill got the fifth and one out of the sixth before giving way to Fernando Cruz. He got the first out, but got into a bad count against Dylan Beavers before having a 3-1 fastball mashed for a game-tying home run. Cruz has really been struggling of late, finally seeming to be bitten by his shoddy command. Even though he wound up stranding him, he got ahead of Leody Taveras 1-2 before hanging him a cookie of a splitter for a double. His fastball has never been highly regarded, so the regression in splitter command is really hurting him.
View Link
One-time Yankee Rico Garcia was rudely greeted by a 108 mph bullet single by Lombard, who advanced to second on a diving play by Basallo at first to retire Wells, but he bounced back to escape unharmed. Brent Headrick got the ball in the eighth, and all seemed well until Alonso smashed a ball down the left-field line for a go-ahead… foul ball? It looked fair live; it looked fair on replay too, but it was inexplicably called foul both on the field and in the replay room. That’s a bizarre one, but it kept the game tied after Pete struck out three pitches later.
View Link
Advertisement
Cam Sanders was next up for Baltimore, getting in trouble with his command. Two hit batsmen and a walk in between loaded the bases with two outs, prompting Craig Albernaz to go to the bullpen. Yennier Cano came in to face Lombard and got what he wanted, a weak ground ball, but with Lombard’s blazing speed, it was too slow. He beat out the go-ahead RBI infield single to make it 4-3 Yankees.
View Link
Two pitches later, Chisholm added some insurance on a ball that barely got away from Yohel Pozo, sliding in to make it 5-3. It looked like he hurt his hip/oblique on a back pick after the Lombard single (which would be the second infield injury of the game), but he looked fine on that play. While an insurance run is always appreciated, this one was especially so, as the Alonso would-be-homer now would not have changed the result of this game.
View Link
Advertisement
Suddenly, with the lead, Aaron Boone called on Paul Blackburn for the eighth. Basallo snuck a slow grounder through the left side with one out, and Beavers worked a two-out walk to put the tying run on base for Taveras, but Blackburn induced a first-pitch pop fly to send this baby to the ninth.
The Yanks would get a chance to tack on against Alex Hoppe, but went down in order after a strike-em-out-throw-em-out double play. David Bednar would take the ball, looking for save No. 29. He got a groundout from Colton Cowser, struck out a pinch-hitting Christian Encarnacion-Strand, and got a flyout from Holliday to win it. After being robbed in his last at-bat, Alonso was left in the on-deck circle.
View Link
The Yankees go for their first three-game sweep at Camden Yards since August 2019 tomorrow night at 6:35 p.m. It’ll be Gerrit Cole against Kyle Bradish on YES.
Box Score
Read the full article here