Even If Robertson’s Door Might Not Be Shut Entirely, Penguins Must Shift Gears

With the days ticking before Dallas Stars superstar winger Jason Robertson was set for his arbitration hearing on Jul. 25, the pressure was on GM Jim Nill and the Stars to get something settled beforehand, whether a deal or a trade.

And, on Tuesday, it finally happened.

Advertisement

Dallas signed Robertson to a one-year, $12 million deal, avoiding arbitration. Because Robertson filed, the Stars are not eligible to extend him long-term until Jan. 1, at which point he would only be able to extend for a maximum of seven years under the new CBA or be dealt to another team, where he could extend for six years. Or, of course, he could walk to free agency on Jul. 1, 2027.

While the speculation is fascinating, the most likely outcome is that Robertson and the Stars come to a long-term agreement to kick in for the 2027-27 season, when the team will have the free cap space to make it work. However, until an extension is actually inked beyond Jan. 1, the door remains open for Robertson to go elsewhere as soon as sometime next season.

So, the Robertson discussion can be shelved for now. But, even if the door to acquiring him is cracked open, that doesn’t mean the Pittsburgh Penguins should wait for it to swing back open.

As it was well-documented over the last several weeks, the Penguins were the NHL team most legitimately linked to Robertson in trade rumors. It was clear that GM and POHO Kyle Dubas is enamored with Robertson. NHL Insider Elliotte Friedman said that the two teams had legitimate talks about a potential trade that never got across the finish line.

Stars Find Stars Find Short-Term Robertson Solution Jason Robertson’s eleventh-hour bridge deal avoids a messy arbitration, betting on looming cap relief from Tyler Seguin’s expiring contract to secure the prolific winger’s long-term future in Dallas.

Advertisement

So, to a large extent, all the smoke surrounding Robertson and the Penguins certainly had a flame. And, hey, that spark could be reignited if January comes and goes without a new deal between the Stars and Robertson.

But, in order for Dubas and the Penguins to progress and move forward with their plan to take a legitimate step toward contention this season, they have no choice but to shift their focus to other potential game-changers on the market.

Dubas has reiterated several times over his desire for the Penguins to land a 20-something elite talent, and those intentions have been complicated as a result of the changing market. That talent will come at a premium, and Dubas – especially after the NHL Draft and the Leo Carlsson offer sheet situation – is very likely hyperaware of that.

Of course, it’s all speculation as far as whether or not Robertson was Dubas’s main target or still is. But, even if that’s the case, pivoting to another talent – perhaps, a center – can help the team in the short- and long-term almost as much as Robertson can. Should they land a center such as Shane Wright or Dawson Mercer, they may be able to plug in long-term as a serviceable second-line center or a good third-line center.

4 Centers For Penguins To Target In Trade Market At some point, Pittsburgh needs to address its glaring need for a top-six center if they hope to compete short- and long-term. And there are some potential options for them.

Advertisement

Maybe they seek a higher-end left defenseman like Alexander Nikishin to help shore up the left side. Maybe they add another winger in the Egor Chinakhov mold such as his old teammate, Kent Johnson. Robertson may have been the biggest prize on the market, but there are still plenty of options out there who can help the Penguins next season and beyond.

And, perhaps, Dubas can target a center or a defenseman now, and then the Penguins will get lucky next summer if Robertson elects to go to free agency or doesn’t sign long-term with Dallas. There is an avenue to acquire talent now while holding out hope that Robertson – or, even bigger-name players like Connor McDavid and Auston Matthews – might be available next summer.

For now, Dubas would be wise to shift to plan B and put plan A on the backburner. Really, it’s the only choice they have if Dubas is to go through with his summer ambitions and add someone this summer who will make the Penguins take a sizeable step toward contention next season.

‘There Were Some Pretty Legitimate Talks’: Penguins, Stars Reportedly Discussed Robertson Trade Prior To Arbitration Filing A Pittsburgh Penguins trade target filed for arbitration on Sunday.

Bookmark THN – Pittsburgh Penguins on your Google News tab to follow the latest Penguins news, roster moves, player features, and more!