2026 Fantasy Football Rankings: Analysis for players ranked 1-12 in Half-PPR

My Top 250 2026 Fantasy Football Rankings are live here, but we need to spend extra time on the first three rounds, where our winnings are mostly made. It’s nearly impossible to come back from a dud pick in these beginning rounds, and if you drafted Jaxon Smith-Njigba in Round 3 last year, then you were in the money. Today’s half-PPR focused column looks at just the first 12 picks in my rankings, with 13-24 and 25-36 editions of this column coming later this week. Stay tuned.

Join or create a Yahoo Fantasy Football league for the 2026 NFL season

Gibbs is my 1.01 in half-PPR after finishing fourth overall last year in fantasy points over replacement per game, despite splitting time with David Montgomery (now on the Texans). Gibbs has averaged 25.1 half-PPR points in eight games that Montgomery has missed or played in under 25% snaps, and he should set career highs in volume.

Here’s a chart showing expected fantasy points per game vs. actual fantasy points per game, where Gibbs dominated.

(Hayden Winks)

Isiah Pacheco only signed for $1.8M this offseason on a one-year deal, a sign that his role will be a lot smaller than Montgomery’s.

At the same time, there are other changes to the Lions offense. They have a new OC in Drew Petzig, who was doing some cool things with the Cardinals, specifically in the run game. They also re-tooled their offensive line with mauling veteran C Cade Mays and experienced first-round RT Blake Miller. The Lions OL was average to even below average last year, but they should get back to moving bodies in 2026.

Bijan Robinson, RB2, Falcons

Tyler Allgeier has never missed a game since Bijan Robinson was drafted, so we don’t have the obvious on/off splits that we have with Gibbs sans Montgomery. But I’d imagine Bijan’s numbers would be outrageous without Allgeier. Bijan was the RB3 on RB8 usage last year with Allgeier, who handled 10 inside the five-yard line carries to Bijan’s 11. I will vomit if Bijan is the RB19 in goal-line carry share again.

As a receiver, there’s nothing really to say. He’s amongst the best in the NFL and was the RB2 in receptions per game (4.6). That shouldn’t change much, even if Zachariah Branch will be involved as a manufactured touch player now.

What is changing is the play-caller. Entering from the Browns is Kevin Stefanski, who has adapted his offense to his personnel each season. It’s unclear if this offense will be more geared towards Tua Tagovailoa’s quick, precision style or towards Michael Penix Jr.’s downfield shot-play style. Either way, the ball is going to Bijan, Drake London and Kyle Pitts Sr. all game long. We saw late last year that without London, Robinson can get an outrageous volume, and that’s the benefit of playing in an offense without depth.

I’m a bit concerned about this OL paired with this QB tandem, but that shouldn’t hurt Bijan’s fantasy output much. He’s locked into the top-five in all non-Superflex formats. Robinson’s market projections are nearly identical to Gibbs; 1,224 rushing yards, 599 receiving yards and 9.5 rushing TDs.

Ja’Marr Chase, WR1, Bengals

Chase is the WR1 on WR1 expected points in games with Joe Burrow healthy over the past three seasons, averaging 21.5 PPR points per game. The only receivers close to matching him over that span are Puka Nacua, Amon-Ra St. Brown, CeeDee Lamb and Malik Nabers. Two of them are downgraded by new competition (Lamb with George Pickens) or injury (Nabers).

Here’s a look at expected fantasy points per game vs. actual fantasy points per game at the wide receiver position, in which Ja’Marr Chase has performed best.

(Hayden Winks)

Burrow, Chase, Tee Higgins and Chase Brown are healthy right now, and the defense has at least added some pieces this offseason. It’s not a surprise to see the Bengals fourth in projected points in the betting markets.

Chase has a case as the 1.01 in full-PPR, too. The depth of WR has decreased because more teams are using TEs and running more, increasing the value of the truly elite WR1s. Pairing Chase with three RBs by the Round 6/7 turn is a great way to start drafts in 2026.

Nacua’s 23.8 PPR points per game were 3.4 more than the WR2 overall (Jaxon Smith-Njigba) last season. Over the past two seasons, only Chase is in his neighborhood. And over his entire career, Nacua has the most receiving yards per game (95.3) in NFL history. HISTORY.

The Rams offense projects for the most points in the NFL, per the betting markets, and the competition for targets around him is the same. Just 33-year-old Davante Adams and a bunch of TEs.

Nacua’s upside and floor are already obvious, but there is one spot that gives him even more of a ceiling: the red zone. Adams had a 27% target share in the red zone compared to Nacua’s 17%. Adams scored 13 RZ TDs to Nacua’s six. That could change at any point, especially if Adams’ hammy acts up.

Outside of the red zone, Nacua caught 8.1 receptions per game (LMAO) on a 33% target share. It’s a good thing if Sean McVay wants to mix in 3-TE sets, as it’s just easier for Nacua to stand out and earn a target.

As long as his off-field decisions don’t catch up to him on the field, Nacua is a no-brainer top-four pick in all formats. In full-PPR, Nacua is my 1.03. In half PPR, Nacua is my 1.04 and I’m considering a move up to 1.02 given the lack of depth at WR in the middle rounds.

Christian McCaffrey, RB3, 49ers

McCaffrey is coming off 450 touches, including the postseason. That’s rare. It’s why he easily finished as the RB1 overall in expected half-PPR points (22.6 per game) and the RB1 overall in actual fantasy points (21.4). If he stays healthy, McCaffrey is obviously an elite RB1. The two primary questions are: 1) what are the odds he stays healthy, and two) what level of an elite workload will he have?

Historically, RBs coming off 400+ touches miss time and are less efficient. That’s even more true in this age-29 range. It’s far more likely McCaffrey does not repeat what he did last year. That’s okay!

Kyle Shanahan has said it was incredible that CMC was able to play every week on that workload, but it’s unsustainable. He later said, “I want him to have more juice. I want him to be fresher. He doesn’t have to take that beating when it’s unnecessary. I’m hoping we can have some other guys step up more this year so you don’t feel like you need him on the field every play.”

The lack of juice was evident in the analytics:

Here’s where 49ers RB Chrisitan McCaffrey stacks up.

(Hayden Winks)

Shanahan noted that the receivers being better this year will allow that to happen. The 49ers also added a rookie RB in Kaelon Black to have some new depth behind CMC. I believe Shanny will use CMC less on a per-game basis. That was 23.7 touches per game last year, so I’d think 19-20 is a more appropriate range. Once again, that’s okay!

The 13 games of McCaffrey handling 19 touches per game is very much worth a first-round pick in fantasy considering his goal-line and receiving work. Anything worse than that is impossible to project, and anything better than that is how you win your fantasy league.

Jaxon Smith-Njigba, WR3, Seahawks

JSN arrived in a huge way without DK Metcalf and Tyler Lockett in his way. He was the WR2 on WR7 usage, averaging 99.6 receiving yards per game including the postseason. His 35% target share dwarfed the next closest, Amon-Ra St. Brown (32%). And he didn’t do it as a screen merchant either. Only 8% of his targets were screens.

Smith-Njigba’s explosion was entirely tied to being a better downfield threat. His average depth of target as a rookie was 6.1 yards downfield, then 8.6 as a sophomore and then finally last year jumped to 11.1. He had 20 yards per game more than he did in 2023-24 on his targets 15+ yards downfield.

Some credit belongs to Sam Darnold for being second in completion percentage over expected (+10.0%) on these deep targets, and Darnold is back with the same OL.

Other credit belongs to OC Klint Kubiak, who called an offense 10th in play action rate and played at the third-fastest pace in neutral situations. The hard part with JSN’s 2026 projection is baking in the new play-caller after Kubiak took the Raiders’ head coaching gig.

Enter new OC Brian Fleury. He might be the least talked about new play-caller this year because he hasn’t been a play-caller before. Nobody knows. Fleury comes from the Shanahan tree, and he’s coached with Kyle Shanahan himself on the Browns in 2014 and then for the past seven seasons with the 49ers. He didn’t directly know Seattle coach Mike MacDonald to my knowledge, yet got the job.

Former QB Brock Huard, who has connections to the team, said this about Fleury: “I know he crushed the whiteboard. I can say that confidently … I know in the interview process it was pretty overwhelming to everybody in the room that his years under Kyle, and his understanding of situational ball, and the level and the depth and the detail was pretty overwhelming, because there were strong in-house candidates, a number of them.”

That makes me feel a lot better about the Seahawks offense in 2026, even if JSN’s yards per target (10.5) and completion percentage over expected (+10.2) are bound to regress. Smith-Njigba still projects as a top-five fantasy WR with regression baked in.

Jonathan Taylor, RB4, Colts

Taylor is the RB3 on RB3 overall usage over the past three seasons since coach Shane Steichen arrived. He’s had low-end RB1 and elite RB1 moments depending on how smooth the QB play has been.

Taylor was the RB19 on RB3 usage without Daniel Jones last year, but he was the RB1 overall (22.4 half-PPR points) on RB2 usage with him through 13 weeks. If we exclude those five wobbly games with Jones playing on a broken leg, then Taylor jumps to 25.9 half-PPR points per game. So what sample is best to use with Jones coming off a torn right Achilles in 2026?

Taylor is unlikely to repeat last year, as the Colts were seventh in points per game and eighth in EPA per play. They’re currently projected to be the No. 15 scoring offense per the betting markets. That’s okay. Taylor will be top-five in usage on an average offense, while in the prime of his career at 27 years old. An injured Jones is still tiers above 2025 Philip Rivers, and the Colts may need Taylor even more without Michael Pittman.

Taylor can’t be projected in the Gibbs and Robinson tier because he was only the RB15 in receptions per game (2.7), but Taylor can get as hot as them if the Colts can catch fire like they did in 2025. He is appropriately priced as a mid-first-round pick ahead of the James Cook and Ashton Jeanty tier of RBs.

Taylor projects for 1,249.5 rushing yards and 11.5 rushing touchdowns in the markets, while Cook (1,199-10.5) and Jeanty (1,030-10.5) sit a slight tier below.

Amon-Ra St. Brown, WR4, Lions

The Sun God has three straight seasons with double-digit TDs and 115+ receptions. Unreal, but there isn’t a lot to say about what to expect. I’ll leave you with one split:

When Montgomery either missed the game or finished with five carries (10 game sample), St. Brown averaged 20.9 PPR points and 21.8 expected points. Both are WR1 overall. In those games, he’s averaged 8.4 receptions, 102.5 yards and 0.60 touchdowns. His average depth of target drops, as he becomes an extension of the run game.

Well, Monty is gone. Obviously, Gibbs will take over a lot of his production, but the Lions could be slightly more pass heavy in 2026, especially with the rest of the division ranking eighth, 10th and 20th in projected points. Detroit is third.

St. Brown is projected for 1,199.5 receiving yards and 8.5 receiving touchdowns in the live markets. That would be his worst season since 2022.

Justin Jefferson, WR5, Vikings

Jefferson is about to remind everyone that he’s arguably the best WR in the NFL.

Before the disaster class of the 2025 Vikings QBs, Jefferson was averaging the most PPR points per game (20.1) among WRs from 2022-2024 if we also remove the Josh Dobbs and Jaren Hall games. That was 100.1 receiving yards, also the most over that sample.

Kyler Murray is far closer to the Kirk Cousins and Sam Darnold tier of QB than he is the J.J. McCarthy, Carson Wentz, Dobbs and Hall tier. And Kyler’s best throws (downfield and sideline shots) are what Jefferson thrives at and what coach Kevin O’Connell pushes for as a playcaller.

The Vikings were 26th in points per game last year and now project to at least be 20th, according to the betting markets. That feels low to me, after O’Connell has made every QB look better than their talent (aside from JJM). Kyler has produced great seasons out of DeAndre Hopkins (2020 – 88 YPG and 2022 – 80 YPG) and Trey McBride (2024 – 72 YPG) attached to the worst franchise in the NFL. Jefferson doesn’t have the infrastructure that Chase, Nacua and St. Brown has, but he’s a lot closer to them now that Kyler is in house.

Saquon Barkley, RB5, Eagles

Barkley is the RB6 on RB5 usage over the past two seasons as an Eagle. Only Taylor is averaging more carries per game (20.1) and only Derrick Henry is averaging more rushing yards per game (101).

Of course, it was the tail of two seasons. Barkley was the RB1 overall in 2024 (21.6 half PPR points per game) as a Super Bowl champ before falling to RB14 last year when the Eagles were 19th in scoring. Which season is more likely? Probably neither.

The Eagles are projected for the 12th-most points per the betting markets with a new play caller and without A.J. Brown. Last year’s OC ran out of ideas quickly, while new OC Sean Mannion comes from a very efficient and balanced Packers offense that allowed RB Josh Jacobs to be a first-round caliber player. Barkley will miss GOAT OL coach Jeff Stoutland, but there’s hope that RT Lane Johnson (nine games), LG Landon Dickerson (14 games), and C Cam Jurgens (14 Games) play more and play healthier.

The area he can improve on is short-yardage efficiency. Last year, Saquon scored one rushing TD on 11 carries inside the five-yard line, on a brutal -85.9% rush yards over expected. That is absolutely not a Saquon stat. That’s an injured OL stat, and it’s a sign for positive regression.

If Saquon does split the difference between RB1 and RB14, then he’s a great pick at 14th overall on Yahoo, especially in half-PPR or standard. Saquon’s floor seems pretty insulated after seeing the offense bust last year, so it’s fair to ask who has the best ceiling between Saquon, Cook (11th in ADP), Jeanty (12th) and De’Von Achane (13th) in their offenses. To me, that’s pretty clearly Saquon.

CeeDee Lamb, WR6, Cowboys

Lamb has averaged 90 receiving yards per game from 2022-2025 when Dak Prescott has started. He’s the WR3 on WR5 usage and a 26% target share (WR5) over that span.

With George Pickens balling out last year, Lamb averaged 89 receiving yards per game on a 26% target share, if we remove his two injured games. He was the WR8 on WR6 usage, with the only real difference being he scored 0.25 touchdowns per game rather than his baseline of 0.37. Long story short, Pickens’ breakout just made the Cowboys a better offense. It didn’t really matter for Lamb’s fantasy production.

Well, the Cowboys are sixth in projected points this year with the same HC, OC, OL, RB, TE and WR rooms. Dallas’ defense should go from laughable to pretty good, but this should remain a team that will play fast on offense (second in neutral pace) and press the right button in terms of scheme (play action, motion, etc.).

Lamb (1149 receiving yards and 7.5 receiving TDs) is a slight tier down from Chase (1324-10.5), Nacua (1299-7.5) and Smith-Njigba (1324-8.5) in the live markets, but he compares almost identically to late first-round picks St. Brown (1199-8.5) and Jefferson (1149-7.5). Lamb is a top-12 player, even in half-PPR.

Kenneth Walker III, RB6, Chiefs

The Chiefs signed Kenneth Walker III to a three-year, $43 million contract with $28M guaranteed because their RB room has been dreadful for years. The combination of Patrick Mahomes, Andy Reid, C Creed Humphrey and RG Trey Smith has elevated the rushing success rate, but it hasn’t created nearly enough explosives. Compare that to the Seahawks, who have had a way worse OL than the Chiefs since 2022:

Here’s a look at which team success rate vs. explosive play rate (plays 15+ yards).

(Hayden Winks)

That’s all Walker, who finally got the backfield to himself down the stretch last year, resulting in a Super Bowl MVP. Walker’s boom-bust style will smooth out with better interior blocking and an elite QB next to him, especially entering the actual prime of his career as a 25-year-old.

The Chiefs are still relatively weak at receiver and seem to be hinting at a scheme change in 2026 with OC Eric Bieniemy back in house. They are going to run the ball more under center, I think. If they don’t have the WRs to beat man coverage, then they need to punish light boxes and create explosives on the ground. It’s why Walker was such a perfect fit this offseason.

On top of that, Walker faces one of the shallowest RB depth charts. It’s Emari Demercado ($500K guaranteed), undersized fifth-round rookie Emmett Johnson, and converted WR Brashard Smith behind him. Who is stealing any goal line touches? Who is preventing him from a career-best season as a receiver?

If he sets a career high in touches per game (currently at 18) this season as expected, then Walker has a mid-range RB1 season well within his range, especially in half-PPR. The Chiefs are 11th in projected points according to the betting markets, but Mahomes looks well ahead of schedule and should be in the starting lineup from the get go.

We also have the history of Reid and RBs, dating back to Duce Staley, Brian Westbrook, Jamaal Charles and LeSean McCoy, who is a great comp for Walker. In his final three seasons with McCoy, Shady’s 17-game pace was 1,825 scrimmage yards.

Let’s just hope Walker’s core holds up.

Read the full article here